HistoryGeek07 wrote:
I know this board is several years old. However, I am posting to clear up the confusion over the Charles/George translation. Some people have said that the translator messed up by putting George instead of Charles, but if you look at the words and think about the historical context you can see the translator did not mess up. In verse 7 it is saying that, upon the victory of Bonnie Prince Charlie, Catholicism and godliness will reign and King George (the king of Great Britain who was fighting Charles at the time) will be left behind with nothing. It makes perfect sense.
Actually, the Scottish Gaelic in verse 7 correctly says Seòirse (= "George"). One of the translations erroneously has "Charles" instead of "George" (the opposite of what you have stated). So CaoimhínSF and Franc were correct in stating that the translator messed up.
CaoimhínSF has added all the corrections into his first translation above.
